Faking It Helps and Hurts

The first time I heard the phrase “fake it till you make it,” I was in my Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction training at UMass, where it was offered as a helpful and thought-provoking tool in the context they were teaching. It struck me as both amusing and familiar, and it reminded me of advice I once gave my daughter when she was starting school.

She was painfully shy and afraid of rejection. I encouraged her to imagine someone who was friendly and popular, and asked, “What do you think made her so popular?” Based on her answers, I offered a few scripts and suggestions on how to dress or interact, not to turn her into someone else, but to help her feel safe enough to show up as herself. It worked. She never became the most outgoing person, but she gained the skills and confidence to express her identity and find her place in the group. She eventually became a very successful young woman.

Years later, as a coach, I began noticing how the phrase had changed. What once served as a starting point for growth had become a strategy for constant performance and self-promotion. I questioned the impact it was having on those who took it literally. The message I kept hearing was: If you want to make it, you have to fake it.

Many blame social media for making us more “fake,” and in some ways this is true. But shaping our image is not new. We have always adapted to the moment, adjusting our tone to fit in, presenting curated versions of ourselves in social settings, job interviews, CVs, parties, and rituals. This is how we survive in many ways; we create, connect, and expand our understanding of the world by trying on different versions of ourselves, figuring out who we are, who we are not, and who we might become. It is a human path of self-discovery. And, don’t get me wrong, social media can still offer real creativity, information, and entertainment.

Somewhere along the way, “fake it till you make it” became more than advice; it became a selling point. What begins as a tool for connection turns into a performance for algorithms. We shape ourselves into personal brands, chasing validation instead of reflection, losing sight of who is watching or why we started performing in the first place. The mask, worn too long, hardens into a persona we dare not take off. Success built on a false image can become a trap, especially when we neglect the person behind it.

And when the performance fails to deliver the validation we seek, we are left with no one responding which becomes unsettling. What began as a stretch or coping strategy starts to take over. The role we created to connect begins to weigh us down. If we are not rooted in a clear sense of who we are or why we are doing this, that lack of feedback can creep in as anxiety, disconnection, and loneliness. We may get good at playing the part but lose touch with the person underneath. The performance gets noticed, but the person, not so much. Eventually, the question comes: Who am I, really, if I stop pretending?

Still, pretending is essential. Children play at being adults, rehearsing the world they are growing into. Adults fake confidence before a speech or take on a voice of authority when guiding their children. These are acts of courage, care, and curiosity.

But they are meant to be temporary steps in the experience itself. The trouble starts when pretending becomes the default, and we stop asking: Is this really me? What is the purpose behind the act? Is it helping me grow, or keeping me stuck?

I often think of that moment in The Wizard of Oz (which I watched many times as a child), when Toto (the dog) pulls back the curtain, revealing that the great and powerful Wizard is just an ordinary man pulling levers, hiding behind smoke and sound effects. Flustered, he tries to salvage the illusion: “Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain!” But the truth is out, and eventually he admits: “I’m a very good man, but a very bad wizard.”

The moment is revealing not only because his image slips, but because it shows how someone can become so invested in the act that they lose sight of who they are. The Wizard wanted to be great and powerful, admired and respected by the people of Oz, but he ended up isolated and afraid, hidden behind a screen of his own making. At the end of the film, he is grateful to be found out, to let go of the illusion, and to return to Kansas, his real home. A metaphor, perhaps, for coming back to his true self.

We all wear masks to learn, to cope, to survive, to connect, to create, to move into something new. However, when the mask becomes embedded in how we present ourselves to the world, we risk forgetting who we fundamentally are. Like the Wizard, we may have good intentions, but if we lose touch with the person behind the curtain, we risk mistaking the performance for the person.

Faking it, when guided by care and intention, can be a meaningful and a necessary stepping stone. When driven by fear or habit, it becomes our very own trap. That is why taking healthy breaks from our made-up selves matters. Connection that does not require performance helps us reset. We find it in physical presence, conversation, play, sport, music, or time in nature. These simple moments bring us back home, remind us of who we are, and give us the space to grow.

LinkedIn ↗